The Red Lipstick Lie—and What Actually Works

YOU'VE BEEN LIED TO ABOUT RED LIPSTICK.

The idea that one red fits all? Cute in theory, tragic in execution. Real talk: red lipstick isn't just red lipstick. Undertones matter. Intensity matters. You matter. And the red that makes you feel like Beyoncé at the Grammys? It's out there—we just need to match it to your melanin.

This is your no-fluff guide to finding a red lip that hits like it should. Let’s break it down by tone and undertone.

LIGHT SKIN

• Cool undertones: Think blue-based reds like cherry or raspberry. They brighten your whole face and make your teeth look whiter.

• Warm undertones: Orange-reds and tomato shades add warmth and pop. Avoid anything too cool or vampy—it can wash you out.

TRY:

• MAC Ruby Woo – the classic matte blue-red

• NARS Dragon Girl – a soft matte with a fiery punch 

MEDIUM TO OLIVE SKIN

• Cool undertones: Try true reds or berry-based shades that bring balance without overpowering.

• Warm undertones: Brick reds, terracottas, and burnt reds were made for you.

TRY:

• Fenty Beauty Stunna Lip Paint in Uncensored – Rihanna knew what she was doing

• Maybelline Color Sensational Made for All Lip stick in Red For Me – legit tested on 50+ diverse skin tones

BROWN TO DEEP SKIN

• Cool undertones: Deep berries and wine reds = chef’s kiss.

• Warm undertones: Brown-based reds, mahogany, oxblood—go bold or go home.

TRY:

• Pat McGrath MatteTrance in Elson – rich, luxe, and dramatic

• Fashion Fair in Radiant Red – made specifically for melanated skin

TIPS FOR THAT RED TO REALLY POP

• Exfoliate first. Dry flakes and red pigment? A nightmare combo.

• Hydrate with balm, then blot so your lipstick sticks.

• Line it. Keeps the edges sharp and prevents feathering.

• Apply, blot, reapply. It's the grown woman move.

FINAL WORD?

Rules are cute, but confidence is the only requirement. If you love it, wear it. Red is a power move—and your skin deserves one that amplifies, not erases.

Go find your red.